TheGaggle
Politics • Culture • News
Our community is made up of those who value the freedom of speech, the right to debate and the promise of open, honest conversations.

We don't agree on everything but we never silence our followers and value every opinion on our channel.
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
The Gaggle Book Club: Benny Morris’s "The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949"

Each week, the Gaggle Book Club recommends a book for Gagglers to read and—most important—uploads a pdf version of it.

Our practice is that we do not vouch for the reliability or accuracy of any book we recommend. Still less, do we necessarily agree with a recommended book's central arguments. However, any book we recommend will be of undoubted interest and intellectual importance.

This week's selection is Benny Morris’s "The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949" (1988). This was a landmark work that fundamentally altered the historiography of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War and the origins of the Palestinian refugee crisis. His research, based on newly declassified Israeli archives, challenged the traditional Israeli claims that Palestinians fled voluntarily, obeying orders to leave allegedly issued by Arab leaders. Morris debunks the claim that Arab leaders ordered mass evacuations. While some isolated orders existed, most refugees fled because of fear, violence or expulsion.

However, Morris disputes the claim that Israel pursued a carefully pre-planned policy of ethnic cleansing, though he does acknowledge that the Israeli Defense Forces and the Haganah did engage in deliberate expulsions and the destruction of villages. They also conducted massacres and spread fears of massacres in order to clear villages.

In his 2004 work, "The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited," Morris revises some of the conclusions he reached in his earlier work. In 1988, he had argued that there was Israel had not pursued a systematic expulsions policy. In 2004, Morris argued that expulsions were far more widespread and far more intentional than he had first thought. More seriously, Morris had by now thoroughly reassessed his position. In interviews after 2000, he argued that the 1948 expulsions should have been more complete. He claimed that leaving large Arab populations in Israel created long-term security problems. According to him, the ethnic homogenization of other states, such as Poland and the post-1948 Indian subcontinent, had prevented future conflicts.

It is interesting to compare Morris's book with the work of Ilan Pappé. Pappé argues there was indeed a deliberate, premeditated plan of ethnic cleansing of Palestine, while Morris maintains that while expulsions happened, they were not systematically pre-planned. The two differ sharply on the role played by David Ben-Gurion. According to Morris, Ben-Gurion supported some expulsions but did not order a mass ethnic cleansing campaign. According to Pappé, on the other hand, Ben-Gurion masterminded a systematic ethnic cleansing policy. Morris argues that local commanders made many expulsion decisions on the ground and that, while Ben-Gurion did little to stop the expulsions, he did not personally orchestrate them. Pappé argues that Ben-Gurion and other Zionist leaders intentionally designed and executed a plan to remove Arabs from what became Israel.

Morris, though critical of Israel’s past, remains ultimately a Zionist and a champion of the Jewish state. Over time, he became increasingly radical in his Zionism, arguing that the reluctance on the part of Israel's leaders to expel all of the Palestinians left the Jewish state with long-term, insoluble problem. Pappé, by contrast, rejects Zionism entirely, calling it a settler-colonial ideology that displaced Palestinians, and supports a one-state solution.

Benny Morris’s "The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem" was a groundbreaking work that dismantled traditional Israeli narratives and forced Israelis to take confront the darker side of the state's founding. Whether it's forced Israelis to adopt a more humane approach toward the Palestinians is a different matter altogether.

The_birth_of_the_Palestinian_refugee_problem,_1947-1949_--_Benny_Morris_--_Cambridge_Middle_East_library,_Cambridge.pdf
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Posts
Articles
TG 1869: The Gaggle Talks To Hans Mahncke

George Szamuely and Peter Lavelle sat down for a long conversation with legal and political analyst Hans Mahncke about the lawfare that has been unleashed against the Trump administration.

00:58:30
TG 1868: Has Trump Found The Formula To Cover A U.S. Exit From Vietnam?

George Szamuely and Peter Lavelle discuss President Trump's latest claim, made during an interview with ABC News, namely, that he had prevented Russia from conquering all of Ukraine, and wonder whether it could serve to rationalize a U.S. exist strategy from Ukraine.

00:27:40
TG 1867: End Of The Vietnam War 50 Years On

George Szamuely and Peter Lavelle discuss the history and end of the Vietnam war, and wonder what lessons, if any, anybody has learned from that protracted conflict.

01:18:15

Patrick Webb
@RealPatrickWebb
·
14 m
BREAKING: Former NSA Mike Waltz was reportedly told to resign by Trump due to holding secret meetings with foreign leaders, which seemingly angered the president, per WSJ.

https://x.com/ErikSolheim/status/1918472072935698596

15 hours ago

Was the Biden presidency a set-up to get us to accept Trump 2.0?

@7SEES_
with
@Geopolitics_Emp
express their views:

"I am under the personal belief that Joe Biden's presidency being as catastrophic as it was, was sort of done intentionally to endear people towards Trump. and get public sentiment behind him as though he's fighting something that he is very provably a part of. Oh, I fully agree with that. I think looking back in hindsight, it was almost like a clownish, a very in idiocracy fashion, exaggerated the clownishness of the Biden presidency and his dementia and falling asleep and walking, you know, in different off the stage in the wrong way. And it's like that was clearly all a setup to endear us towards, you say, swing the pendulum towards Trump. And a number of my guests are agreeing. You were mentioning something about the cult previously."

Follow me for more clips, opinion, and knowledge on Technocracy & Transhumanism. ...

17 hours ago
January 21, 2023
More Leftie Than Thou
"Jacobin" Magazine Celebrates A Strike Against Ol' Blue Eyes

Here at "The Gaggle" we have very little time for the "more Leftie than thou" school of thought--that's the approach to life according to which the only thing that matters is whether you take the right position on every issue under the sun from Abortion to Zelensky. No one in the world meets the exacting standards of this school of thought; any Leftie leader anywhere is always selling out to the bankers and the capitalists. The perfect exemplar of this is the unreadable Jacobin magazine. 

The other day I came across this article from 2021. It's a celebration of trade union power. And not simply trade union power, but the use of trade union power to secure political goals. Of course (and this is always the case with the "more Leftie than thou" crowd), this glorious, never-to-be-forgotten moment on the history of organized labor took place many years ago--in the summer of 1974 to be exact. Yes, almost half a century has gone by since that thrilling moment when the working-class movement of Australia mobilized and prepared to seize the means of production, distribution and exchange. 

Well, not quite. Organized labor went into action against...Ol' Blue Eyes, the Chairman of the Board, the Voice; yes, Frank Sinatra. Why? What had Sinatra done? Sinatra was certainly very rich, and he owned a variety of properties and businesses. But if the Australian trade union movement were, understandably, searching for the bright, incandescent spark that would finally awaken the working class from its slumber there were surely richer, greedier, more dishonest, more decadent, above all more Australian individuals it could have discovered. Australia was never short of them. Rupert Murdoch immediately springs to mind. Why Sinatra?

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals