The Gaggle Music Club: Anton Bruckner’s Symphony No. 8 in C minor
This week's selection for The Gaggle Music Club is Anton Bruckner’s Symphony No. 8 in C minor. Completed in 1887, and revised in 1890 after initial rejection by conductor Hermann Levi, this work is widely considered to be the crowning achievement of Bruckner's symphonic output and one of the most remarkable symphonies in Western music history.
Anton Bruckner (1824–1896) was an Austrian composer known for his massive symphonic structures, deeply spiritual outlook and distinctive harmonic language. A devout Catholic and a church organist by training, Bruckner developed a symphonic style that fused Beethovenian form and Wagnerian harmony with a cathedral-like symphonic structures. Bruckner’s symphonies often unfold in massive, symmetrical blocks of sound that bring to mind the recesses of a Gothic cathedral.
His movements build slowly, often with long crescendos, as if the music were reaching upward toward the divine. Bruckner's symphonies often seem to embody prayer, awe and contemplation—not in a literal liturgical sense, but in mood and scope.
Bruckner composed nine numbered symphonies (plus two unnumbered) and sacred choral works such as Te Deum. The Eighth was Bruckner's last completed symphony, thus making it his final full statement. Critics regard it as more expansive than the Seventh and more spiritually searching than the Fourth or Fifth. Bruckner himself called it “the most important of all” his works. It is a precursor to Mahler, Shostakovich and even Sibelius in its command of orchestral mass. Its climactic finale, uniting all previous themes, is a symphonic apotheosis rarely matched in any composer’s work.
The symphony consists of four movements:
I Allegro moderato (C minor): Three thematic groups: brooding first theme, a noble second theme and a lyrical third. Characterized by heroic struggle, with a coda that foreshadows triumph. The movement represents the soul’s confrontation with fate, in the Beethovenian tradition.
II. Scherzo: Allegro moderato: A dark, driving scherzo that stands in stark contrast to a pastoral, serene, almost celestial theme. The alternation captures Bruckner’s signature contrast between earthly turbulence and heavenly calm.
III. Adagio: One of the most sublime slow movements in the symphonic repertoire. Structured as a long, slow arch, building to an overwhelming climax with Wagner tubas, cymbals and harp. It combines romantic yearning with liturgical solemnity.
IV. Finale: Integrates themes from all previous movements in the final coda—a kind of musical Last Judgment. Bruckner unifies the symphony’s disparate materials in resounding affirmation. This finale is not just a summation but a transfiguration.
Bruckner incidentally was one of the most devoted Wagnerians of his time. His reverence for Wagner bordered on religious. Bruckner referred to Wagner as “the Master” and even kept a picture of him in his room. 1865, after hearing "Tristan und Isolde," Bruckner became a lifelong disciple of Wagner’s harmonic and orchestral innovations. He dedicated his Third Symphony (1873) to Wagner, even visiting him at Bayreuth to present it in person.
Bruckner's music, especially from the Third Symphony onward, shows Wagner’s influence in its lush orchestration and use of leitmotivic elements. Wagner respected Bruckner as a musician but did not champion Bruckner’s music in any public or significant way.
However, Bruckner, more than Mahler, is often seen as Wagner’s true heir. Bruckner fused Wagner’s chromaticism and orchestral power with the Beethovenian symphonic tradition.
Bruckner’s Symphony No. 8 is his greatest symphony—a visionary and spiritual epic. It combines Beethovenian rigor, Wagnerian color and deep Catholic mysticism. Without question, it stands as one of the greatest symphonic achievements in Western music.
In this performance from 1996, on the occasion of the 100th anniversary of the death of Anton Bruckner, at the Stiftskirche St. Florian in Linz, Austria, Pierre Boulez conducts the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra.